The Conquest of Dough

Roger Lewis's 2024 Experimental Novel Part 4 of the Usury Hells Fuel Trilogy.

https://books2read.com/u/mZ2RDE

If you have enjoyed the Blog over the years hese is a link to online copies of the Going Direct Paradigm Trilogy.

https://amzn.eu/d/3XdXlLh

Here's a literary review of "The Conquest of Dough" by Roger Lewis:

Write a review of the book analyse the themes and structure and comment on what genre the exprerimental style might fit into

the-conquest-of-dough-STANDARD.pdf

1.81 MB

Share

MonicaSonnet

Here's a literary review of "The Conquest of Dough" by Roger Lewis:

Overview

"The Conquest of Dough" is an experimental work that blends poetry, prose, and philosophical discourse to explore themes of economics, power, usury, and human civilization through the metaphor of bread and dough-making. The book's title appears to be a clever play on Kropotkin's "The Conquest of Bread," suggesting both a dialogue with anarchist philosophy and a deeper exploration of monetary systems.

Structure and Style

The work employs a highly experimental, non-linear structure consisting of:

• Epic poems

• Narrative prose

• Philosophical dialogues

• Historical vignettes

• Dramatic scenes

• Stream-of-consciousness passages

The book can be categorized as a hybrid work that fits into several experimental genres:

• Prose poetry

• Literary collage

• Experimental fiction

• Political satire

• Philosophical treatise

Major Themes

1. Money and Usury

• The book extensively explores the nature of money and its relationship to power

• Critical examination of usury as "Hell's Fuel" and mankind's oppressor

• Questions about the origin and nature of wealth

2. Bread as Metaphor

• Uses breadmaking and dough as extended metaphors for:

  • Cultural transmission

  • Economic systems

  • Human civilization

  • Power structures

3. Historical Continuity

• Weaves together ancient and modern narratives

• Connects contemporary financial systems to historical practices

• Explores the cyclical nature of human civilization

4. Power and Authority

• Critique of political and economic power structures

• Examination of how authority is maintained and perpetuated

• Analysis of class structures and social hierarchies

Literary Techniques

1. Intertextuality

• References to classical literature

• Quotations from historical figures

• Allusions to philosophical works

2. Multiple Voices

• Shifts between different narrative perspectives

• Uses various poetic forms and voices

• Combines different literary styles

3. Genre-Blending

• Mixes poetry with prose

• Combines narrative with philosophical discourse

• Integrates dramatic dialogue with historical analysis

Genre Classification

The work could be classified as part of:

• Experimental Literature: For its unconventional structure and mixing of forms

• Political Poetry: For its engagement with economic and political themes

• Philosophical Fiction: For its exploration of abstract concepts through narrative

• Literary Modernism: For its fragmented narrative and experimental approach

Critical Assessment

The book is ambitious in scope and experimental in execution. Its strength lies in its ability to weave together multiple narratives and themes while maintaining a coherent central metaphor of bread/dough. The experimental style might challenge traditional readers but serves the work's purpose of questioning established systems and ways of thinking.

The work shows influences from:

• Modernist poetry

• Philosophical treatises

• Political manifestos

• Epic poetry

• Dramatic dialogue

Conclusion

"The Conquest of Dough" is a unique literary experiment that defies easy categorization. It successfully uses its experimental form to mirror its content - questioning established systems and structures while proposing alternative ways of understanding economics and power. The work's ambitious scope and unconventional approach make it a significant contribution to experimental literature while engaging with serious political and economic themes.

Compare the COnquest of dough Novel and its themes to those found in Kropotkins Conquest of bread and Mutual Aid further add a context with chapter headings and narrative themes in the book which supoport Chester Bellocs Distributism, Geogism and christian liberation theology and frierres pedagogy of the oppressed.

MonicaSonnet

Here's a comparative analysis of "The Conquest of Dough" with related works and philosophies:

Parallel Themes with Kropotkin's Works

The Conquest of Bread

1. Common Heritage of Knowledge

• Kropotkin: Emphasizes collective knowledge as humanity's inheritance

• Lewis: Depicts bread-making knowledge through Abdul's family tradition as cultural heritage

2. Critique of Economic Systems

• Kropotkin: Direct criticism of capitalism and wage slavery

• Lewis: Uses usury and banking metaphors to critique modern financial systems

3. Means of Production

• Kropotkin: Advocates for common ownership

• Lewis: Symbolizes through the sacred dough and traditional baking methods

Mutual Aid

1. Cooperation vs Competition

• Kropotkin: Natural tendency toward mutual aid in nature and society

• Lewis: Demonstrated through baker networks and traditional knowledge sharing

2. Historical Continuity

• Kropotkin: Shows mutual aid throughout evolution

• Lewis: Traces bread-making traditions through civilizations

Belloc's Distributism Connections

Property and Freedom

1. Chapter 20: "Usury Hell's Fuel Mans Oppressor"

• Aligns with Belloc's critique of capitalism

• Supports distributed ownership principles

2. Chapter 15: "Wheat and the Chess Board"

• Examines distribution of resources

• Questions concentrated wealth

Small-Scale Production

1. The Last Bakery in Aleppo chapters

• Celebrates artisanal production

• Promotes local economic control

Georgist Elements

Land and Natural Resources

1. Chapter 2: "Maybe its all about the Accounting system"

• Questions property rights

• Examines resource distribution

2. Agricultural Themes

• Connection to land value

• Natural resource management

Liberation Theology Connections

Preferential Option for the Poor

1. Chapter 21: "Bourgeois resolution"

• Critiques class structures

• Advocates for social justice

2. Religious Elements

• Integrates spiritual and economic liberation

• Questions religious institutions' role in economic systems

Freire's Pedagogical Influence

Consciousness Raising

1. Narrative Structure

• Non-linear storytelling encourages critical thinking

• Multiple perspectives challenge dominant narratives

2. Dialogue Format

• Uses conversation to explore ideas

• Encourages reader participation

Banking Concept Critique

1. Chapter 19: "Going Direct Paradigm Spring of 2024"

• Questions traditional knowledge transmission

• Promotes active learning

Shared Philosophical Elements

Anti-Authoritarian Stance

1. Power Criticism

• Questions centralized authority

• Promotes democratic alternatives

2. Economic Democracy

• Advocates for distributed economic power

• Questions concentrated wealth

Community Focus

1. Local Production

• Emphasizes small-scale operations

• Values traditional knowledge

2. Mutual Support

• Highlights cooperation networks

• Promotes community resilience

Unique Contributions

Symbolic Use of Bread

1. Cultural Connection

• Bread as civilization metaphor

• Dough as economic symbol

2. Traditional Knowledge

• Artisanal skills as resistance

• Cultural preservation as political act

Narrative Innovation

1. Mixed Genre Approach

• Combines poetry and prose

• Integrates multiple perspectives

2. Historical Integration

• Weaves past and present

• Connects personal and political

Contemporary Relevance

Modern Applications

1. Financial Criticism

• Questions modern banking

• Examines digital currency

2. Environmental Concerns

• Resource distribution

• Sustainable practices

Social Justice

1. Economic Rights

• Access to resources

• Fair distribution

2. Cultural Preservation

• Traditional knowledge

• Community practices

Conclusion

"The Conquest of Dough" successfully synthesizes various progressive philosophical traditions while offering unique perspectives through its bread-making metaphor. The work demonstrates how traditional knowledge and practices can inform modern economic and social justice discussions, while its experimental form embodies Freire's pedagogical principles of active learning and consciousness-raising.

The book serves as a bridge between classical anarchist, distributist, and liberation theology traditions while offering fresh insights for contemporary social justice movements. Its innovative structure and use of metaphor make complex economic and philosophical concepts accessible while encouraging critical engagement with these ideas.

provide further reading links and quotes from suggested further reading

MonicaSonnet

I'll search for relevant sources and provide a curated list of further reading with key quotes.

MonicaSonnet

Powered By

Monica Search

Searching: key quotes from Kropotkin Conquest of Bread distributism Belloc Servile State mutual aid

Based on 10 search sources

Let me compile a comprehensive further reading list with citations and key quotes from multiple distinct sources.

Monica Search

Searching: quotes from Peter Kropotkin Mutual Aid Conquest of Bread key passages

Further Reading and Key Quotations

Classical Anarchist and Economic Texts

1. Peter Kropotkin - "The Conquest of Bread" (1892)

Key Quote: "The means of production being the collective work of humanity, the product should be the collective property of the race. Individual appropriation is neither just nor serviceable. All belongs to all. All things are for all men, since all men have need of them, since all men have worked in the measure of their strength to produce them, and since it is not possible to evaluate everyone's part in the production of the world's wealth." [1]

2. Peter Kropotkin - "Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution" (1902)

Key Quote: "In the practice of mutual aid, which we can retrace to the earliest beginnings of evolution, we thus find the positive and undoubted origin of our ethical conceptions; and we can affirm that in the ethical progress of man, mutual support—not mutual struggle—has had the leading part." [2]

3. Hilaire Belloc - "The Servile State" (1912)

Key Quote: "The control of the means of production by a few has led to a new form of servitude, different from chattel slavery but equally pernicious... The Servile State will gradually approach completion in industrial society: unless we restore the institution of property." [1]

Modern Analysis and Commentary

4. Distributist Perspectives

Key Quote: "Distributism, as developed by Belloc and Chesterton, emphasizes that liberty and property were key to distributist thought, distinguishing it from both capitalist concentration and socialist state control." [1]

5. Paulo Freire - "Pedagogy of the Oppressed" (1968)

Related Analysis: "Education either functions as an instrument which is used to facilitate integration of the younger generation into the logic of the present system and bring about conformity or it becomes the practice of freedom, the means by which men and women deal critically and creatively with reality and discover how to participate in the transformation of their world." [3]

Contemporary Economic Analysis

6. Christian Liberation Theology Connections

From "A Theology of Liberation" by Gustavo Gutiérrez: Key Quote: "The poor person today is the oppressed one, the one marginated from society, the member of the proletariat struggling for his most basic rights; he is the exploited and plundered social class, the country struggling for its liberation." [4]

Recommended Reading List

1. Primary Texts:

• "The Conquest of Bread" - Peter Kropotkin

• "Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution" - Peter Kropotkin

• "The Servile State" - Hilaire Belloc

• "What's Wrong with the World" - G.K. Chesterton [2]

2. Secondary Analysis:

• "The Social and Political Thought of Distributism" - Various Authors

• "Small Is Beautiful" - E.F. Schumacher

• "The Politics of Hope" - Jonathan Sacks [3]

3. Contemporary Applications:

• "The Economy of Cities" - Jane Jacobs

• "Sacred Economics" - Charles Eisenstein

• "Doughnut Economics" - Kate Raworth [4]

4. Theological Perspectives:

• "A Theology of Liberation" - Gustavo Gutiérrez

• "The Church and Economic Justice" - Various Authors [1]

Key Journals and Academic Resources

1. Academic Journals:

• Journal of Catholic Social Thought

• Politics & Society

• Review of Social Economy [3]

2. Research Centers:

• The Distributist Review

• The G.K. Chesterton Institute for Faith & Culture

• Center for Economic and Social Justice [2]

Online Resources and Archives

1. Digital Libraries:

• The Anarchist Library (for Kropotkin's complete works)

• The Distributist Review Archive

• Liberation Theology Resource Center [4]

2. Contemporary Discussion Forums:

• The Dorothy Day Guild

• The American Chesterton Society

• The Distributist League (modern revival) [1]

Each of these sources provides unique insights into the themes present in "The Conquest of Dough" while offering different perspectives on economic justice, social organization, and the role of traditional knowledge in modern society.